Customer area
London 020 7822 4000
Brighton 01273 838734
Classic Car Disputes
You are here: Home / Collector Cars / Classic Car Disputes
searchSearch
call-answerCall Us
new-email-envelopeEnquiry
list-menuMenu
×
×
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
    • ×
    911 Oldtimer roter Sportwagen

    Classic Car Disputes

    Putting you in the driving seat

    Healys Collector Car Group acts for a wide range of clients, from private owners, collectors, and racing enthusiasts to racing teams, dealers, auction houses and restorers. We protect your investment and should there be any disputes, we will resolve them on your behalf, aiming to secure the best results.

    In the event of a dispute:

    • Misrepresentation claims – when a car is purchased from a dealer or auction house and you later find that you were misled on the condition or the history of the car
    • Identity disputes – when parts salvaged from one car are used in another and both are claimed to be the original car
    • Title disputes – when ownership of a car is claimed by more than one person
    • Restoration disputes – when a car is sent to a restorer and the work completed is not to the correct standard
    • Price disputes – when a deal falls through due to an overvaluation of the car or a buyer pulling out of the sale due to lack of funds
    • Mediation – a less contentious approach when disputes arise
    • A network of industry and expert partners – including car historians, valuers, marque specialists, accountants, banks, insurance providers and more
    Call Us Today
    Call our London office on 020 7822 4000 or our Brighton office on 01273 838734. You can also contact us online.
    Call Us Today
    London: 020 7822 4000 Brighton: 01273 838734 Or you can contact us online: Contact Us
    Key Contacts
    Headshot of Clive Robertson
    Clive Robertson
    Head of Classic Car Group
    Headshot of Robert Johnson
    Robert Johnson
    Partner
    Meet the team
    Classic Car Disputes capabilities
    Classic Car Disputes experiences
    • Advising a US owner of an historic 70's Porsche 911 race car, who became aware of another car residing in Europe, bearing the same chassis number, but  differing race livery. Both cars carried divergent histories in early years, but which merged from the eighties. Both cars have been examined by expert marque engineers, whilst painstaking research has been undertaken both in the Americas and Europe, the outcome of which is yet to be concluded.
    • A client based in Hong Kong was the successful bidder at auction in London of a Bugatti carrying a body by James Young. Post auction, the buyer felt "unsure" about the car, when it was discovered that the sale was by the US auction house and not by an unconnected third party. In the event the "seller" could not prove title and was obliged to accept the return of the car, whilst refunding the purchase price as well as settling legal costs and all expenses.
    • Acting for an owner of a Jaguar D Type confronted by a claim from another party claiming that he owned the same, genuine chassis. As with all D Types, the tub has a chassis number, which number is also stamped on suspension and other parts. After a career spent racing the tub of the Jaguar was deemed "tired", when the parts were removed and re-fitted to a new tub, whilst the original tub was discarded. In due course the discarded tub was "refreshed with genuine new parts. The question arose as to which of the cars could be deemed to be genuine. The parties reached a reasonable conclusion.
    • Competition engines, by the very nature of their intended use, are subject to extreme stress and therefor wear. Competent re-builds usually produce the number of working hours expected, but in a small, but significant number of those rebuilds, poor workmanship can bring about major failure. Independent examination by expert engineers has often provided the basis on which we have founded a number of successful recovery actions.
    • Following a year of ownership of an Alfa Romeo Guilia Spider, the purchaser who had bought the car as a present for his daughter discovered that the car and documentation carried reference to two different chassis numbers, which anomalies were not disclosed, nor apparent at inspection. Advice is now being sought on the basis of the remedied that may be available based upon the misrepresentation of the seller.
    • Advising a client who wished to establish the authenticity of his 1949 Alfa Romeo 6c SS This car was bought at auction in the UK, having spent many years in Argentina. Doubts had been raised as to the authenticity of the car, to the extent that it had been labelled a "fake". An exhaustive forensic examination of the car was undertaken. In particular, a sample of metal was cut from the chassis and following analysis, was found to have been to have been cast in the year of manufacture, so establishing provenance beyond a reasonable doubt.
    • Appointed in 2004 to manage the dissolution of AC Car Group Limited, following a century of production ranging from 3 wheeled cars to the iconic AC Cobra.
    Classic Car Disputes insights
    • Advancing Money to Your Loved Ones? Is it a Gift or a Loan?

      27th April 2022

      When money passes from one member of a family to another, questions can all too easily arise as to whether it is a loan or a gift. Proper legal documentation is by far the best means of avoiding such ambiguity but, as a Court of Appeal ruling showed, even that does not always succeed in defusing disputes. Continue reading »

    Classic Car Disputes awards
    Classic Car Disputes news
    • Advancing Money to Your Loved Ones? Is it a Gift or a Loan?

      27th April 2022

      When money passes from one member of a family to another, questions can all too easily arise as to whether it is a loan or a gift. Proper legal documentation is by far the best means of avoiding such ambiguity but, as a Court of Appeal ruling showed, even that does not always succeed in defusing disputes. Continue reading »

    Call Us Today
    London: 020 7822 4000 Brighton: 01273 838734 Or you can contact us online: Contact Us
    CLASSIC CARS / COLLECTOR CARS